Plan a trip to Banderas Bay and three names come up again and again: Puerto Vallarta, Nuevo Vallarta and Sayulita. They sit close together on the map and share an airport, but they are very different places to wake up in, and the Puerto Vallarta vs. Nuevo Vallarta question alone fills whole forum threads.

We live and work in Puerto Vallarta, and all of our rentals are here, so we have an obvious bias. We also know that Nuevo Vallarta and Sayulita are the right answer for some travelers, and we will say so. This guide compares the three, explains who each suits, and shows how to stay in one and visit the others. If you are also weighing Los Cabos, our Cabo vs. Puerto Vallarta post follows the same format.
Puerto Vallarta, Nuevo Vallarta and Sayulita at a glance
| Puerto Vallarta | Nuevo Vallarta | Sayulita | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vibe | A real city: Malecón, Old Town, galleries, street life | Planned resort area: all-inclusives, marinas, golf | Small, laid-back surf town |
| Beaches | City beaches in town, coves and boat-only beaches to the south | Long, flat beaches in front of the resorts | A surf beach at the center of town |
| Food and nightlife | The most restaurants, bars and nightlife in the region | Mostly inside the resorts, fewer independent spots | Compact center with restaurants and beach bars |
| Walkability | Romantic Zone and Malecón are very walkable | Car, taxi or resort shuttle for most trips | Walkable town center |
| Best for | Food, culture, nightlife, LGBTQ+ travelers, variety | All-inclusive stays, families staying put, golfers, quiet | Surfers, younger travelers, boho shopping |
| Getting there from the airport | Airport is in town, about 20 to 30 minutes to the Romantic Zone | About 20 minutes, across the river | About 45 minutes to an hour up the coast |
Puerto Vallarta: the city on the bay
Puerto Vallarta is a working city in the state of Jalisco, not a resort built for visitors, and that is the point of staying here. The Malecón, the seaside boardwalk, runs along downtown, and just south of it the Romantic Zone (Zona Romántica, the Old Town) packs in more restaurants, bars, galleries and nightlife than anywhere else in the region. It also has a well-known LGBTQ+ scene; our LGBTQ+ travel guide covers it in depth.
The city suits food lovers, people who want nightlife and culture within walking distance, and anyone who gets restless staying in one place. From here you can be on a boat to a south shore beach in the morning and at a table on Basilio Badillo that night. The international airport (PVR) is in Puerto Vallarta itself, on the north side of town near Marina Vallarta, so arrival day is short.
The trade-off is that it is a city. The Puerto Vallarta beaches in town are busier than a resort beach, with vendors, restaurants and water sports, and the quiet coves are a taxi or boat ride south. If you want a pool, a swim-up bar and nothing to decide, Nuevo Vallarta does that better. For a fuller picture of the neighborhoods, see our guide to Puerto Vallarta’s map and neighborhoods.
Where to stay in Puerto Vallarta
The Romantic Zone is the pick if you want to walk to everything: Los Muertos Beach, Restaurant Row and the Malecón are all on foot from buildings like Soho PV, Loft 268 and Zenith. The Hotel Zone, between downtown and the Marina, is where our beachfront buildings Harbor 171 and Grand Venetian are, with the sand right outside the door. South of town the coast gets hillier, and our homes in Amapas and Conchas Chinas sit above the bay for a quieter stay with views. Our guide on where to stay in Puerto Vallarta compares them in detail.
Nuevo Vallarta: resorts and long beaches
Cross the Ameca River north of the airport and you leave Jalisco for the state of Nayarit, and Puerto Vallarta for Nuevo Vallarta, the first stop on the Riviera Nayarit. It is a planned resort area, laid out around large all-inclusive resorts, marinas and golf courses, with long, flat beaches in front of the hotels.
Nuevo Vallarta suits travelers who want to check in and stay put. If your ideal week is an all-inclusive with a kids’ club, a swim-up bar and dinner reservations you made at breakfast, this is where that week happens. Golfers have courses close at hand, and the overall pace is quieter than the city. It is also about 20 minutes from the airport, a little closer than the Romantic Zone and Puerto Vallarta’s southern neighborhoods, which matters with small children or a late flight. And despite being in a different state, it keeps the same time as Puerto Vallarta.
The trade-offs are the flip side of the same coin. There are fewer independent restaurants and less street life, most of the nightlife is inside the resorts, and getting anywhere means a car, a taxi or the resort shuttle rather than a walk. If you want to play somewhere different during your stay, our guide to golf courses around Puerto Vallarta has more options.
Sayulita: the surf town
Keep going north along the Nayarit coast and you reach Sayulita, a small surf town with a very different personality from either Vallarta. The beach in the middle of town has beginner-friendly waves, the streets around it are full of shops, cafes and beach bars, and the whole place has a laid-back, bohemian feel that is a big part of its appeal.
Sayulita suits surfers and anyone who wants to learn, younger travelers, and people who like to browse small shops between swims. It is compact enough to walk everywhere, and evenings are about a beach bar and a sunset rather than a cocktail list.
The trade-offs: it is small, so there is less variety for a long stay if you are not surfing, and in high season the streets and the beach get busy. It is also the farthest of the three from the airport, about 45 minutes to an hour by car, so plan your arrival and departure days around the drive.
Puerto Vallarta vs. Nuevo Vallarta: which is better for you?
For food and nightlife, Puerto Vallarta. The Romantic Zone and the Malecón have the most restaurants, bars and galleries in the region, and you can walk between them. Nuevo Vallarta’s dining is largely inside the resorts.
For an all-inclusive week, Nuevo Vallarta. If you want everything in one place and you are happy not to leave the property much, the large resorts here are set up for exactly that, with long beaches and golf nearby. Puerto Vallarta has resorts too, but the city is built around going out.
For families, it depends on the family. Young children and parents who want a kids’ club and a pool steps from the room point to Nuevo Vallarta. Families with older kids who want tacos, boat trips and something different every day do well in a Puerto Vallarta condo with a kitchen and a rooftop pool.
For LGBTQ+ travelers, couples and anyone who wants to walk, Puerto Vallarta. The Romantic Zone is the center of the region’s LGBTQ+ scene, and walkability changes a vacation: no car, no shuttle schedule, no waiting for a taxi after dinner. In the Puerto Vallarta vs. Nuevo Vallarta debate, this is usually what tips people one way or the other.
Sayulita vs. Puerto Vallarta: stay or day trip?
For most travelers, our honest advice is to stay in Puerto Vallarta and visit Sayulita for a day. You get the surf town’s beach, shops and a long lunch in daylight, and you come home to a city with far more choice of restaurants, neighborhoods and things to do on the other six days. Sayulita is a popular day trip from Puerto Vallarta for exactly this reason, and plenty of organized day trips and tours include it.
Do the opposite if surfing is the point of the trip. A surfer wants to walk to the break at dawn, not drive to it, and Sayulita’s beginner-friendly waves reward a few days of lessons in a row. Travelers who want a small-town week with no city at all should also base in Sayulita and treat Puerto Vallarta as the day trip.
The Sayulita vs. Puerto Vallarta choice is really about pace: a week in one small town against a week in a city with the town as an outing. As for Nuevo Vallarta vs. Sayulita, they could hardly be more different: one is resorts and quiet, the other is surfboards and busy streets, and the right one depends entirely on whether you want to be served or to wander.
Other bases around Banderas Bay
Bucerías is a beach town between Nuevo Vallarta and Sayulita, a middle ground for travelers who want a town feel on the Nayarit side. La Cruz de Huanacaxtle is a marina town a little farther along the coast. Punta Mita (also written Punta de Mita), at the northern tip of the bay, is the luxury option: resorts and private villas, and the usual answer when people ask about Puerto Vallarta vs. Punta Mita is that Punta Mita is for a high-end resort stay and Puerto Vallarta is for everything else.
Why we recommend Puerto Vallarta as a base
We are biased, because this is home. But here is the case. Puerto Vallarta has the most variety of the three: city beaches and quiet coves, taco stands and tasting menus, a walkable Old Town and hillside neighborhoods, all in one city. You can eat somewhere new every night and walk home.
The airport is in town, so there is no long transfer; our guide to flying into Puerto Vallarta covers routes and timing. And the city works as a hub: Sayulita, Bucerías and Punta Mita are day trips north along the coast road, and the beaches of Las Ánimas and Yelapa are a boat ride from the Los Muertos pier.
A condo with a kitchen, and often a rooftop pool, gives you resort comforts without resort walls. Our team meets you at the building, and when you book direct there are no platform fees. See our condos in the Romantic Zone, the Hotel Zone and the hills south of town.
FAQ
Is Nuevo Vallarta or Puerto Vallarta better?
Neither is better for everyone, which is why the Puerto Vallarta vs. Nuevo Vallarta question keeps coming up. Puerto Vallarta wins for restaurants, nightlife, culture and walkability, and it has the airport in town, while Nuevo Vallarta wins for all-inclusive resorts, long flat beaches, golf and a quieter pace. Choose by how you want to spend your evenings: out in a city, or by the resort pool.
Is Nuevo Vallarta part of Puerto Vallarta?
No. Nuevo Vallarta is a separate planned resort area north of Puerto Vallarta, across the Ameca River in the state of Nayarit, and part of the Riviera Nayarit. The two share Banderas Bay and the Puerto Vallarta airport, which is why travelers often lump them together. It also keeps the same time as Puerto Vallarta.
Is Sayulita worth a day trip from Puerto Vallarta?
Yes, for most visitors. You get the surf beach, the shops and a long lunch, then return to the city for dinner. If you plan to surf for several days or want a small-town week, stay in Sayulita instead and visit Puerto Vallarta as the day trip.
Which is better for families: Puerto Vallarta or Nuevo Vallarta?
Nuevo Vallarta suits families who want an all-inclusive with a kids’ club and a pool steps from the room, and it is closer to the airport than most of Puerto Vallarta’s southern neighborhoods. Puerto Vallarta suits families who want a condo with a kitchen, a rooftop pool and a different outing every day, from beach days to boat trips. Both work; the question is how much you want to leave the property.
How do you get from Puerto Vallarta to Sayulita?
By taxi, rideshare, local bus along the coast road, or an organized day tour. The drive takes roughly an hour from the Romantic Zone, more in traffic, so leave in the morning. Rideshare apps will get you there, but a ride back through an app can be hard to find, so arrange your return with your driver or take one of the taxis that wait in the town plaza.


